Sunday, April 12, 2009

Do you think lily should've been with james or snape?

lily and snape were sooo close, ti was adorable! who knew?

Do you think lily should%26#039;ve been with james or snape?
I think she should%26#039;ve been with James, because she loved him. Snape however, was a good friend. It probably wouldn%26#039;t have been a good relationship for Lily, as Snape is needy (thought we were supposed to be friends? Best friends?) and controlling (I won%26#039;t let you..)and jealous (but, he fancies you! James Potter fancies you!), and wouldn%26#039;t let her hang around with other guy friends, and maybe other girl friends! He was only that way because he never had any friends before. Lily wasn%26#039;t prejudiced they way Petunia was (You%26#039;re that Snape boy. You live down by the river on Spinner%26#039;s End), judging him on who he was or what he wore. She was his friend because, mainly, he taught her about their world, but she was also his friend because he was nice and kind to her. It would%26#039;ve been a good relationship for Snape, however, because he would%26#039;ve been good, and had true love and a family. I think when Lily broke of their relationship it pushed him to the dark side even more than he already had been.


Also, he%26#039;ld probably have more confidence, since he had %26quot;taken%26quot; the girl Potter fancied. All in all, it was really sad, Snape%26#039;s unrequited love for Lily. Maybe if they had all stayed alive and good, Snape would have been a family friend, just to Lily though!
Reply:well, for Harry%26#039;s sake I would say James. but for Lily%26#039;s sake I would say Snape because he seemed to care so much about her. He loved her for the rest of his life even though he coudn%26#039;t have her.
Reply:well i think she should of been with james, because if not, harry wouldn%26#039;t be real.
Reply:i kinda wished that she would of been with snape, for the fact they were such good friends since the beginning, but then again, she probably would have turned out to be a death eater or a %26#039;worker%26#039; for the dark lord like snape.
Reply:i really would have liked it if lily and snape stayed close. i mean im glad that lily and james got together, it just makes me feel soooo bad that snape loved lily all these years. ok just think about it...snape probably didnt have any friends when he was younger and when lily started talking to her he probably had an immediate crush...and that turned into love...and i donno it just makes me feel so bad for him!!! like when he did the patronus thing and dumbledore said %26quot;after all these years?%26quot; and snape was like %26quot;always.%26quot; AWWWWWWWWWWW! it made me cry...and whn i think about it again it makes me wanna cry even more!


and when snape was dying he definately wanted to give harry the truth...and then he said %26quot;look...at...me%26quot; and they looked into eachother%26#039;s eyes...he was imagining looking into lily%26#039;s eyes!!!!!!!!!!!!! thats so sad. :( :( :( :(





anyway... see ya :)
Reply:I wish that Lily would have stuck with snape as a friend to help him get over his muggle issues, but she clearly only thought of him as a friend. He loved her but probably wasn%26#039;t willing to let her be independent. I did feel terribly for him because he seemed to be capable of great love, but it wouldn%26#039;t have worked with Lily.
Reply:I think she made the right decision and was with james because even though he was a bully sometimes his firneds weren;t death eaters, and by marrying james she had harry who ultimatly destroyed voldemort, and that might not have happened if she was with snape.
Reply:james...only because harry
Reply:I serioulsy felt soo bad for snape..But without James..harry wouldnt be there.
Reply:James, cause if that never happened, Harry wouldn%26#039;t exist! But Snape wouldn%26#039;t be all emo and goth and stuff, cause he would be happy =)



computer

No comments:

Post a Comment